UGC questions › Making ads that convert
TL;DR
AI UGC ads are allowed on every major ad platform in 2027, but more of them now need a label. AI videos are cheap to make, often under a few dollars each. The catch is that most ads don't become winners, so cost per winning ad matters more than cost per video. Independent tests show AI ads can get clicks, but they lose a lot of them when labeled as AI.
Key findings
TL;DR: AI UGC is any "creator-style" ad where software makes some or all of it. It ranges from a fully fake person to small AI edits on real footage.
We sort AI UGC into four kinds, because the rules and results differ for each.
| Kind | What it is | Label risk |
|---|---|---|
| AI avatar | A software-made person talks to camera | Highest: counts as fully AI-generated on TikTok and as a synthetic performer in New York |
| AI voice over real footage | Real product shots or B-roll with an AI voiceover | Medium: an AI voice clone of the main subject needs a label on TikTok |
| AI product video | Generated scenes of a product being used | Medium to high, depending on how real it looks |
| AI edits to real footage | A real creator, with AI used for captions, background, translation or cleanup | Low: minor edits are generally exempt |
Our comparison of AI UGC and real creators covers when each kind fits. This guide covers what changed for 2027: the rules, the costs and the evidence.
TL;DR: Yes, on all three. TikTok asks for a label on AI-made ads. Meta and Google mostly require labels for political ads, but both now add AI info on their own.
This is how each platform's published rules read as of November 10, 2026.
| Platform | What the rules say | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Meta (Facebook, Instagram) | Advertisers must disclose AI use in ads about social issues, elections or politics in certain cases. Meta adds information to ads it detects were made with third-party AI tools, shown in "About this ad". It says its approach to AI labels in ads "continues to evolve". | Meta, February 2026, updated June 1, 2026 |
| TikTok | AI-generated or significantly edited content can run in ads only with TikTok's AIGC label or your own clear disclaimer, caption, watermark or sticker. Ads Manager has a "contains AI-generated content" setting. A label doesn't make a misleading claim acceptable. | TikTok ads policy: misleading and false content |
| Google Ads | Since July 2026, advertisers can add an AI label without breaking image-overlay rules. Election ads must still tick "altered or synthetic content". | Google Ads policy help |
| YouTube | Creators must disclose realistic altered or synthetic content. Edits for looks, AI-written scripts and cloning your own voice are exempt. | YouTube help |
For a brand running AI UGC on Meta, there's no general self-label rule for commercial ads in Meta's published policy that we could find. Some blogs say otherwise, but we couldn't match their claims to Meta's own text. Meta may still add its own AI note to your ad.
TL;DR: The FTC cares whether the testimonial is true, not whether the person is real. New York and the EU now require clear AI labels in some ads.
| Rule | What it requires | In force |
|---|---|---|
| FTC rule on fake reviews and testimonials | Bans testimonials from people who don't exist or who didn't have the experience described. FTC staff say there's no blanket ban on AI avatars. Courts can impose civil penalties for knowing violations. | October 2024 (FTC Q&A) |
| New York synthetic performer law | Ads that knowingly use a "synthetic performer" must say so conspicuously. Penalties are $1,000 for a first violation and $5,000 after. Audio-only ads are excluded. | June 9, 2026 (Cooley) |
| EU AI Act, Article 50 | Deepfake content, including realistic AI people, must be disclosed as AI-made. | August 2, 2026 (AI Act, Article 50) |
The New York law doesn't say what "conspicuous" means or where the label should go. Several other states have likeness and digital-replica laws, and those change quickly. This page isn't legal advice, so have your counsel check anything that runs in New York, the EU or a regulated category.
A simple test for the FTC rule: if your AI person says "I used this and it changed my skin", someone has to have actually had that result, and the claim has to be true. If nobody did, the ad is a fake testimonial whether the person is real or AI. An AI presenter explaining features ("this serum has 10% niacinamide") is a different kind of ad.
TL;DR: The same rules apply as for a real person. An AI label doesn't fix a claim you can't back up.
There's no special exemption for AI. Health, money and weight-loss claims need the same proof they always did, and Meta and TikTok's health and financial ad policies still apply. An AI "doctor" or "patient" sharing results that never happened combines the two biggest risks: a fake testimonial and an unproven health claim.
In our data on long-running ads, 42% of the ads featuring AI people were also in compliance-sensitive categories like health and finance. Those are exactly the ads that get the closest review.
TL;DR: They can get clicks. But labeled AI ads lose a lot of those clicks, and AI ads can do less for your brand over time.
The best independent evidence we found, with what each study measured:
| Finding | Who and when | What it measured |
|---|---|---|
| Fully AI-made ads got about 19% more clicks than ads made by human experts (4.44% vs 3.73% click-through) | NYU Stern and Emory, 2025 (coverage) | Display ads in a live field test |
| Labeling ads "AI-generated" cut click-through by about 31.5% | Same study | The same ads, with and without the label |
| AI ads scored 14% lower on creative effect and 17% lower on brand effect, even when viewers couldn't tell | Ipsos and Syracuse University, via Harvard Business Review, 2026 | Survey-based ad testing |
| 45% of Gen Z and millennials feel positive about AI ads. Ad executives guessed 82%. | IAB, January 2026 | Survey of 505 consumers and 104 ad executives |
Put together, AI ads can win the first click, especially when nobody knows they're AI. Labels are spreading, and the brand cost shows up even when viewers can't tell. Both make it harder to build a lasting ad account on AI people alone.
Two popular claims, "AI UGC gets 3-5x ROAS" and "AI UGC gets 2-4x higher CTR", have no study behind them that we could find. They mostly appear on pages selling AI tools. Our audit of 45 UGC statistics explains how to check numbers like these.
TL;DR: AI people show up much less often in ads that have run a full year. That may be partly because AI ads are newer.
We looked at 1,571 long-running Meta video ads across 54 markets, each tagged for what appears in it.
| Group | Ads | AI people in the ad |
|---|---|---|
| All long-running ads | 1,571 | 115 (7.3%) |
| Ads running 365+ days | 217 | 4 (1.8% of these ads) |
| Share of AI-people ads that reached 365+ days | 115 | 3.5%, against 14.6% for ads without AI people |
The median AI-people ad had been live 60 days, against 123 days for the rest. One reason could be that realistic AI video is fairly new, so fewer AI ads have had time to reach a year. Even so, it's a useful check on the idea that AI ads can replace an account's long-running winners. Our part 2 run-length study shows how much run length depends on industry, and our first longevity study found no AI avatar presenter among ads that had lasted.
AI people were most common in apps and SaaS (10.1%) and dental and clinic ads (10.0%), and rarest in food and drink (1.1%) and finance (2.7%).
TL;DR: An AI video can cost a few dollars, compared with about $200 for a creator video on one big marketplace. Cost per winning ad is the number that matters.
These were the listed plans on the tools' own pricing pages on November 10, 2026.
| Tool | Monthly plans (US$) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Creatify | $15 to $195 ($10 to $136 billed yearly) | Credit-based; a 15-second avatar clip uses about 5 credits |
| MakeUGC | $29 to $79, billed yearly | Credits vary by model, length and resolution |
| HeyGen | $29 Creator, $49+ Pro, $149 Business | Credit-based |
| Synthesia | $19 Starter, $89 Pro | Lower with yearly billing |
| invideo | $20 to $150 per seat | Lower with yearly billing |
For human creators, Collabstr's marketplace reported an average UGC asking price of about $198 in its 2025 report. That's one marketplace's listed prices, and it doesn't include usage rights, editing or ad management. Our UGC cost guide breaks those costs down.
Cost per video hides two things.
The simple way to compare is:
Cost per winner = cost per finished ad ÷ hit rate
Say a finished AI ad costs $20 after re-rolls and editing, and 1 in 25 becomes a winner. That's $500 per winner. A human UGC ad at $300 with a 1 in 13 hit rate comes to about $3,900 per winner. These numbers are only an example of the method. Nobody has published AI UGC hit rates yet, so track your own for both kinds before you move budget.
TL;DR: AI works well for testing ideas quickly and for apps, explainers and translations. Real people still win where trust, touch and long-running ads matter.
| AI tends to fit | Real creators tend to fit |
|---|---|
| Testing many hooks and angles quickly before filming | Testimonials and before-and-after results |
| App walkthroughs and screen demos | Products people need to see handled, worn or tasted |
| Translating a winning ad into other languages | Health, finance and other high-trust categories |
| Explainer ads with a presenter, not a "customer" | Ads you want to keep running for months |
| Filling B-roll gaps | Audiences that react badly to AI, like many Gen Z viewers |
The pattern we see in buyer discussions on Reddit matches this. Many media buyers describe using AI to "audition" hooks cheaply, then paying real creators to reshoot the hooks that win. The common complaints about AI ads are stiff lip-sync in the first second, comments calling the ad "AI slop" and strong click numbers that don't turn into sales.
TL;DR: Use AI to test fast, label it where rules require, keep claims true and reshoot your winners with real people.
TL;DR: Rules change fast and this isn't legal advice. Some prices and studies came from secondary sources, and we say which.
On Google
Add us as a preferred source and Google shows our UGC ad research more often in Top Stories and AI answers.
Book a 30-minute call. We review your current ads and your offer and see if we're a fit. No retainer required.
Book a Call